12 Cool Multi-Player Signed Sports Cards

I first published this piece in September 2020, before the hobby’s infatuation with on-card autographs really took off. Given the niche’s newfound popularity, I thought it was worthwhile to revisit the piece, update a few cards, and put a new slant on it. What originally motivated me to write it over five years ago was a look through REA’s archives and coming across this incredible 1968 Topps #490 Super Stars card signed by Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, and Harmon Killebrew.

You can see that the card sold for $2,400 in the Spring of 2018. Well, in November 2024, REA sold a different copy, with all three autographs, for $7,800.

At the time, it got me wondering what other cool multiplayer signed cards were available. So, here are 11 more cards you might consider adding to your collection, in addition to that incredible 1968 Super Stars card.

1957 Topps #407 Yankees’ Power Hitters Mickey Mantle and Yogi Berra

SCP sold a signed copy for $7,200 in July 2025; Card Ladder now estimates its price at $9,128.

1963 Topps #242 Power Plus Ernie Banks and Hank Aaron

Heritage Auctions sold a dual-signed copy of this card for $2,760 in February 2024. It’s a lot easier to find single-signed copies.

1954 Topps #139 Ed and John O’Brien

The oldest card on the list is one of the most affordable, because the twin brothers continued to sign for a long time. Ed died in 2014, and John died in June 2025. The following copy sold on eBay in September 2025 for $275.55.

1978 Topps #707 Rookie Shortstops Mickey Klutts, Paul Molitor, Alan Trammel, and U.L. Washington

Finding this card with all four signatures is tough, but they do pop up for sale from time to time; you’ll find quite a few signed by just Molitor and Trammell. This quad-signed copy sold on eBay for $399.99 in July 2025.

1963 Topps #1 National League Batting Leaders Frank Robinson, Stan Musial, Tommy Davis, Bill White, and Hank Aaron

This card last sold publicly, on eBay, for $1,750 in September 2022.

1958 Topps #436 Rival Fence Busters Willie Mays and Duke Snider

From an aesthetics perspective, this is my favorite card on the list, and Heritage sold the following example for $1,403 in March 2025.

1991 Upper Deck #35 Aerial Threats Joe Montana and Jerry Rice

Pristine Auctions last sold a BGS-graded copy of this card in July 2025 for $409.50.

1972 Topps #176 NBA Assists Leaders Len Wilkens, Jerry West, and Nate Archibald

I think this card is criminally underrated; the following example sold for just $153.72 at Goldin Auctions in October 2024.

Ok, it’s a little miscut 😉

1980 Topps Larry Bird, Julius Erving, and Magic Johnson

The GOAT of basketball on-card autos. I’ll reserve my comments for a more in-depth piece in the future, but expect to pay a ton for one today.

1988 Donruss #625 Cal Ripken Jr, Cal Ripken Sr, and Billy Ripken

There are quite a few of these triple Ripken signed beauties on the market; this copy sold on eBay for $325 in September 2025.

1979 Topps #2 NHL Assist Leaders Brian Trottier, Guy Lafleur, Marcel Dionne, and Bob MacMillan

I can’t find a copy of this card that’s been sold in the past few years!

Do you have any other suggestions? Let me know in the comments below.