10 of the Toughest Sports Cards to Track Down

A lot of iconic hobby cards are readily available; they just cost a lot. But others seem to never come to market. Here is a rundown of 10 of the most challenging post-war sports cards to find in the hobby, whether due to scarcity or condition sensitivity.

1958 Topps #66 Bobby Hull 

The recognized rookie of Bobby Hull is hard to find centered. Most often, they have 70/30 centering, at best. 

1963 Fleer #72 Lance Alworth 

The 1963 Fleer Lance Alworth is another tough card to find centered; almost 10% of the PSA graded cards have a qualifier (and those are cards people have even bothered to send in).

1960 Fleer #84 Jim Woodard

The entire 1960 Fleer set is notorious for being released in poor condition. The Woodward rookie is amongst the worst and incredibly difficult to find in Ex-Mt condition or better. Here are the three that were available on eBay in April 2021 when I first drafted this piece:

1986 Fleer #121 Dominique Wilkins

This card always seems to be just a little off-center. It’s one of the most frustrating cards to track down in the classic 1986 Fleer basketball set. Again, almost 10% of PSA graded cards have a qualifier, whereas that percentage is closer to 1-2% for most cards in the set.

1976 Topps #19 George Brett

Here is what PSA says about the 1976 Brett

The 1976 Topps Brett (#19) is one of the most sought-after cards of the decade in high grade. It is considered more valuable in PSA NM-MT 8 or PSA Mint 9 than his rookie. It is very rare for a second-year card of any player to be worth more than that player’s rookie in these grades, but that is precisely the case with Brett. Why? The 1976 Topps Brett is usually found off-center from left to right, preventing many examples from achieving high-grade status. At the time of this writing, no copy has been assigned a grade of PSA Gem Mint 10 as a result.

To this day, PSA has graded 4,390 (up from 2,410 in April 2021) of these cards, 0 PSA 10s, and 33 PSA 9s. That’s almost 2,000 extra graded copies with a high-end growth of just five PSA 9s in 4 years!

1979 Topps #116 Ozzie Smith.

Another oft-graded card that is a rarity in high-grade due to centering issues.

1966 OPC #1 Willie Mays

For such a popular player, good luck getting your hands on one of the 77 (up from just under 50 4 years ago) of these cards that PSA has graded.

1960 Topps #451 Curt Simmons

For 1960 Topps set collectors, the Simmons is one of the most challenging cards to find in nice condition. PSA, for example, has only graded 38 cards at eight or better (without qualifiers) of just over 500 total cards. The card is almost always off-center.

1966 Topps #15 Funny Ring Checklist

The Funny Ring Checklist is another tough one to track down, and it’s super popular. It’s a significantly tough card to grab in nice condition between the wood grain borders, markings, and off-centered cuts.

1964 Topps Hockey #80 Bobby Rousseau #92 Marcel Paille

A pair of 1964 Topps hockey cards completes our list of 10(11) tough-to-find sports cards. Both are short prints, plus there aren’t any Rousseau’s graded above an eight by PSA, and only one PSA 9 of Paille exists.

The reality is that tons of cards are tough to find. Most OPC baseball cards are tough to find in high-grade. If you collect a specific player, like Carl Yastrzemski, his oddball cards, like a 1966 Punchout, are also tough to find, or as a Johnny Bench collector, good luck finding a 1968 Kahn’s full tab. The journey in the post-war card market is half the fun of collecting.

My best advice is to let the community know which cards you have been struggling to find, and maybe someone can help you track them down. Happy collecting!