Once you have recognized the player in a Carl Horner photograph, look again at everything around him. A letter on a jersey may help date the image. A studio stamp may record a change of address. Pencil marks may show where an editor planned to crop the portrait. The photographs in Mastro’s April 2007 Carl Horner Studios Collection offered plenty of these smaller discoveries.
The first installment followed familiar portraits into baseball cards. This time, the interest lies in the evidence preserved by the photographs themselves. Some clues are visible in the catalog illustrations. Others are described in the lot text, especially when they appear on a reverse the catalog does not reproduce.
A uniform that narrows the date
Frank Arellanes, lot 546, wears one of the collection’s most immediately striking jerseys. Across his chest is a large sock-shaped emblem containing the word Boston. Mastro identified the design as a one-year uniform from 1908 and used it to date the portrait to his rookie season.

Pat Donahue, lot 557, appears in the same unusual Boston design. His cabinet makes an excellent companion illustration because it shows how a repeated uniform feature can connect separate photographs. The catalog likewise associated his image with 1908.

A distinctive uniform can be more useful than a broad stylistic impression to narrow a photos date.
When the uniform has been changed
Rube Kroh’s cabinet, lot 548, complicates that method. The catalog noted that his jersey appeared to carry a Chicago C associated with an earlier uniform style (exclusive to 1903), although Kroh did not join the Cubs until 1908. It also described the C as apparently drawn in by Horner’s studio, with the breast-pocket outline removed from the original negative.

Bill Dahlen, lot 550, supplies another example of adaptation. The studio obscured the protrait’s Brooklyn lettering and added N.Y. after Dahlen’s trade (in 1904) from the Superbas to the Giants.

The mount records the business
Across the collection, the mounts carry different forms of Horner’s branding, including Horner-Jordan. These imprints are part of the photograph’s presentation and can contribute to research into the studio’s history.
Red Dooin’s cabinet, lot 542, is especially informative. A prominent stamp announces the Horner-Jordan move to 250 Huntington Avenue, opposite Symphony Hall. Mastro interpreted it as notice to Baseball Magazine’s photograph editors.

The catalog also transcribed editorial instructions from Dooin’s reverse concerning a negative and its fit within a border:
make H.J. [Horner-Jordan] neg to fit space in border #1 Mon. sure finish like sample.
A photographer asking for credit
Danny Murphy’s cabinet, lot 559, carries another revealing story. Mastro transcribed an unsigned message on its reverse addressed to a Baseball Magazine editor, complaining about missing photographic credit and making future supply conditional on proper acknowledgment.
My Dear Mr. Potts, Why is that we do not get credit in your magazine as agreed, we do not care to furnish or rush photos for you unless we get credit under pictures in the BB Magazine.

That message adds a working relationship to the portrait. Someone (likely the studio) supplying photographs cared about how the magazine credited them and was prepared to press the point. The front’s studio mark and credit stamp become more meaningful when read alongside the catalog’s account of the reverse.
Labels need checking too
Even a handwritten player identification can be wrong. Lot 556 was cataloged as Fred Odwell, while Mastro reported that a pencil note on the reverse incorrectly named George Scott. It is a small detail with a useful lesson: a label is a piece of evidence to evaluate.

Taken together, the uniforms, revised lettering, address stamps, and editorial notes reveal photographs that continued to change after the sitting. They moved between studio, publisher, and collector, gathering marks along the way. In part 3 of this series I’ll widen the view again, from individual cabinets to action poses, team arrangements, and a composite that brought the American League together on one sheet.
Happy Collecting!

Be First to Comment