Press "Enter" to skip to content

Hobby Hoarding History: 1,720 Lake to Lake Packers Cards Without a Single Short Print

Sometimes an old auction catalog offers more than a remarkable pile of cards. It offers a reason to question how we explain scarcity.

In its December 2002 catalog, Mastro offered lot 1557: “Humongous 1961 Lake to Lake Packers Football Card Hoard (1,720).” With a $300 minimum bid, the group contained just 14 different players, and that’s where things get interesting.

1961 Lake to Lake Packers Hoard – Mastro

Every card belonged to the set’s non-short-print number ranges: 9–16 and 25–32. Missing from those ranges were only #10 Paul Hornung and #26 Bob Skoronski.

The quantities were substantial. There were 170 Dan Curries, 156 Herb Adderleys, and 151 copies apiece of Andy Cvercko and Ron Kramer. Even the smallest group, Ken Iman, included 40 cards. Mastro described the condition as 75% NM to NM/MT and 25% EX/MT.

That’s a lot of concentrated supply (and a reason to wonder how many 1961 Lake to Lake Packers cards on eBay might trace back to this find).

As I explain in the Oddball Archive’s Lake to Lake overview, cards 1–8, 17–24, and 33–36 are considered short prints. None appeared in this hoard.

But were the short prints originally printed in smaller quantities, or were some cards distributed differently? Perhaps the company retained quantities of certain players, leaving stock that eventually entered the hobby through finds like this.

Mastro suggested an employee connection because none had been redeemed, but offered no documented provenance. Without production or distribution records, we can’t know whether this hoard widened an existing availability gap or helped create it.

Either way, 1,720 cards representing just 14 players, and not a single recognized short print, make this a hoard worth remembering. What collectors consider scarce today depends on more than what came off the printing press.

Happy Collecting!

Be First to Comment

    Leave a Reply