A familiar baseball card can look a lot different when you see the photo behind it; suddenly there’s a lot more to dissect. In Mastro’s April 2007 catalog, those details were the attraction. The Carl Horner Studios Collection offered collectors a chance to study photographs connected to some of the defining images of early baseball cards.
The intro page placed Horner portraits alongside cards of Nap Lajoie, Addie Joss, and Joe Tinker.
The photographer behind the familiar faces
Mastro introduced Carl Josef Horner as a Swedish immigrant who established a photography business in Boston and became an important portrait photographer of major league players. Boston’s place in both leagues gave him access to hometown players and visiting clubs. His studio became “a requisite stop for almost any newcomer to the National or American Leagues.”
The catalog connected his work to issues including E107 Breisch-Williams, T204 Ramly, T206, and Cracker Jack, as well as Sporting Life premiums. The significance of the collection came partly from that circulation.
The title also deserves a little explanation. Mastro described this as a group gathered over many years by an East Coast collector. Many photographs had connections to the Baseball Magazine archives. The collection name should therefore be understood as the auction’s presentation of a collector-built group, rather than evidence that everything had survived together in Horner’s studio.
Addie Joss before the printed card
Mastro dated the Joss portrait to his rookie season with the Cleveland Bronchos and identified its use in the E107 and T206 sets. Joss faces slightly away from the camera, wearing a dark jersey with a large Cleveland C. The pale background makes the outline of his face and uniform easy to study. Compared with the cropped card image, the larger photograph offers more detail.
Nap Lajoie and the image collectors remember
Lot 527 presented the Lajoie portrait that Mastro dated to 1902 and associated with both his E107 and T206 cards. The introductory yellow-background T206 makes a great comparison (pictured above). The head position and expression are the same but the change in color and presentation shows how the photographic image was adapted for a card.
The cabinet also illustrates why image condition and mount condition deserve separate attention. Mastro described wear to the dark mount while praising the preservation of the photograph itself.
Joe Tinker and the long life of a portrait
The Tinker cabinet, lot 525, made a third awesome pairing. Mastro dated the photograph to 1903. The collection’s introductory page in the catalog paired the image with a 1914–15 Cracker Jack card identifying Tinker with the Chicago Federals.
The catalog also reported a transferred image of a woman on the cabinet’s reverse, apparently left through prolonged contact with another portrait.
A familiar photographer and an unfamiliar Speaker
The Tris Speaker cabinet, lot 524, offers an exception to the card connections. Mastro described this young Speaker portrait as an image that never appeared on a baseball card. The cabinet also carried an unusual detail: a commemorative cancellation on its reverse marking the 1987 opening of the “Tris Speaker Station” post office in Hubbard, Texas. According to the catalog, an accompanying photocopied letter from Speaker’s niece listed the photograph among items she later sold to a collector in late 1991.
In the next part of this series, I’ll look at the mounts, uniforms, and editorial markings. They have plenty to say about how Horner’s photographs were made, used, and preserved.
Happy Collecting!
Be First to Comment